Three Decades Back, the Horror Maestro and the Comedy Legend Collaborated for an Underrated Horror Masterpiece

The director's latest project may have revitalized the concept of Black vampires, but the roots of this subgenre trace back to the 1970s cultural movement. Among the most iconic pioneering films was the 1972 classic Blacula. In that film, William Marshall's character is turned by Dracula and cursed with the insulting name “Blacula.” Initially conceived as a stereotype, the performer elevated the role into something regal, providing his character an 18th-century backstory as Mamuwalde, a proud African prince.

Decades later, the comedic star appeared to draw inspiration from Marshall, enriching his own protagonist's lore in the director's take on the Black vampire subgenre: Vampire in Brooklyn. Murphy's Maximillian is a descendant of Dracula whose ancestors fled to Egypt, and later to the Bermuda Triangle, after being hunted to the edge of annihilation. Vampire in Brooklyn proves that tales of African American undead can be humorous, frightening, and intellectually stimulating simultaneously, securing its position in the canon by juggling all three while respecting the subgenre's legacy.

Released three decades back on Oct. 27, 1995, Vampire in Brooklyn is currently streaming on a popular platform, making it an must-see if you want a dash of humor with your scares this Halloween.

An Urban Vampire Story

Like the royal character in Coming to America (the actor's 1988 masterpiece), the vampire lead is pulled to New York City. But rather than traveling from Zamunda to Queens, he emerges from the Bermuda Triangle into Brooklyn, seeking to locate and ensure the continuation of his vampire lineage with an heir of his tribe.

Maximillian arrives in New York aboard a phantom vessel whose sailors has been inexplicably killed, a homage to Nosferatu. The vessel is found by ship inspector Silas Green (John Witherspoon) and his relative Julius Jones (the actor), two of the film's funniest characters. Silas then witnesses a dark creature jump from the ship, dart into an alley, and morph into a man — like the iconic routine from the extended Black or White video. Groovy 1970s-inspired soundtrack starts, setting the mood for a film that expertly mixes scares and laughs.

Creative Visions

Recently after his final entry in the Nightmare on Elm Street series, the director was eager to move beyond his scary movie image and make a more blended comedy (his subsequent project after Vampire in Brooklyn was Scream, which mined horror tropes for both laughs and genuine scares). At the same time, the star aimed to defy assumptions by venturing into a pure scary movie based on vampire mythology. The clash of those artistic aims accounts for the film's exposition-heavy opening of Max's origins and its somewhat slow commencement. But once the film clicks into high gear, it opens up to its assets — like its eclectic cast.

The acclaimed actress, as the object of Maximillian’s affection, plays detective Rita Veder, whose dynamic with her colleague and romantic lead, detective Justice (Allen Payne), brings a procedural element to the story. One of Black cinema’s most praised performers, she delivers a powerful performance with Payne, a well-known actor from the time. Meanwhile, the lead spends the majority of the film with Kadeem Hardison, forming a uproarious classic comedy pair as Hardison’s Julius Jones becomes the vampire's minion. (Seeing Julius descend further into his ghoulish role as his skin decays throughout the film is a highlight of how the star's comedic style elevates the comedy and horror, even when employed by the cast).

Supernatural Romance

When Max and Rita’s paths intertwine and the stars finally share the screen, the movie reaches its peak — the suspense builds, the scares intensify, and their darkly seductive chemistry becomes the focus. The vampire's scheme is to take away all Rita has in her life and then swoop in. He murders her roommate, creates conflict in between her and her partner, and even uses Nutty Professor-esque prosthetics to disguise himself as a clergyman and undermine her faith.

As the plot unfolds, it becomes more darkly romantic, featuring transformations and discoveries of heritage. This leads to a final section packed with seduction, as life and eternal punishment are at stake. The movie ends with a teaser hinting at a possible follow-up, one that might have materialized had the film been more successful. Vampire in Brooklyn earned a modest box office return and received mostly negative reviews upon debut. As years passed, it gained popularity as a beloved classic, with reviewers later praising the filmmaker's work, the electric chemistry Murphy and Bassett, and its sharp blend of frights and fun. The movie shows moments of brilliance that could have been more prominent had everyone involved been in agreement on a unified vision, rather than delivering the tonal hodgepodge audiences received. Nevertheless, Vampire in Brooklyn has deservedly secured its spot in the canon of African American scary movies, an overlooked but impactful film defined by its bold style and unforgettable performances.

Charles Marshall
Charles Marshall

Eleanor Vance is a passionate tabletop gamer and writer, sharing insights on dice games for over a decade.